HOW IS FAULT DETERMINED IN A TRUCK ACCIDENT?

1096 Reviews

CALL (888) 345-9407 FOR YOUR FREE CONSULTATION

Determining who is at fault for a semi-truck accident can be a challenging process. If you are bringing the lawsuit or filing an insurance claim for damages, you must be able to prove that the other driver was negligent.

Contributory and comparative negligence deal with situations in which both parties contributed to the accident. Depending on where you live, you may or may not be able to collect damages if you were partially at fault for the car accident. It is important to understand how the recovery is different under each approach and which one will apply in your home state.

If you have been injured in an 18-wheeler accident, call Zinda Law Group at (888) 345-9407 for a free consultation with an experienced truck accident lawyer.

CONTRIBUTORY NEGLIGENCE

Contributory negligence is the harshest outcome for the plaintiff. If the defendant can prove that the plaintiff contributed in any way to the accident–even as little as one percent–then the plaintiff will not be able to recover any damages. Even if the plaintiff was only slightly at fault, they will not receive compensation.

The following states use the contributory negligence doctrine: Alabama, District of Columbia, Maryland, North Carolina, and Virginia.

COMPARATIVE NEGLIGENCE

Comparative negligence takes into consideration each party’s fault in determining damages. There are two kinds of comparative negligence: pure and modified.

Pure Comparative Negligence

This approach reduces the amount of damages recoverable based on the degree to which the plaintiff’s own negligence contributed to the injuries. The damages the plaintiff recovers will be reduced by their contribution to the accident. For instance, if the total damages were $100,000 and you were found to be 10 percent at fault, you would receive $90,000.

The following states follow this model: Alaska, Arizona, California, Florida, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, Missouri, New Mexico, New York, Rhode Island, South Dakota, Washington.

Modified Comparative Negligence

Modified comparative negligence is the most common approach among the states. In this model, there is an at-fault threshold; if the plaintiff is responsible for more than the at-fault threshold, they cannot recover from the other driver.

The following states have a 50 percent threshold, which means that if the plaintiff is found to be 50% or more at fault for the incident, there is no monetary recovery: Arkansas, Colorado, Georgia, Idaho, Kansas, Maine, Nebraska, North Dakota, Oklahoma, Tennessee, Utah, West Virginia.

The following states have a 51% threshold, meaning that plaintiff can recover if they are 50 percent or less at fault, but not if they are 51 percent or above at fault: Connecticut, Delaware, Hawaii, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Montana, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Jersey, Oregon, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Texas, Vermont, Wisconsin, Wyoming.

GET HELP FROM NATIONWIDE 18-WHEELER ACCIDENT LAWYERS

At Zinda Law Group, our trucking attorneys have helped countless 18-wheeler accident victims recover damages for medical bills, property damages, lost income, pain and suffering, and more.

Our truck injury lawyers will fight tirelessly to protect your rights, and as one of our clients, you will pay nothing unless we win your case.

Call Zinda Law Group today at (888) 345-9407 to receive your free consultation with one of our truck accident lawyers. Meetings with attorneys by appointment only.

Get Your Free Consultation







    PERSONAL INJURY INFORMATION CENTER


    Our Team

    John C. (Jack) Zinda, Founder, Attorney Joseph Caputo, Attorney

    Joseph Caputo

    Burgess Williams, Attorney

    Burgess Williams

    Elecia Byrd, Attorney

    Elecia Byrd

    Neil Solomon, Attorney

    Neil Solomon

    Sean Smith, Attorney

    Sean Smith

    Jason Aldridge, Attorney

    Jason Aldridge

    Ryan Toomey, Attorney

    Ryan Toomey

    Cole Gumm, Attorney

    Cole Gumm

    Brendan McQuaid, Attorney

    Brendan McQuaid

    Chelsea Cates, Attorney

    Chelsea Cates

    Michael Cupero, Attorney

    Michael Cupero

    John Harper, Attorney

    John Harper

    Matt Lightfoot, Attorney

    Matt Lightfoot

    Christina Rosendahl, Attorney

    Christina Rosendahl

    Shivangi Mehta, Attorney

    Shivangi Mehta

    Hanna Bledsoe, Attorney

    Hanna Bledsoe

    Ariana Byrd, Attorney

    Ariana Byrd

    Natasha Wesenberg, Attorney

    Natasha Wesenberg

    Mike Redondo, Attorney

    Mike Redondo

    E. Marvin Romero, Attorney

    E. Marvin Romero

    * Meetings with attorneys by appointment only *

    Awards & Recognition

    AWARDED TO JOHN C. (JACK) ZINDA BY THE NATIONAL TRIAL LAWYERS ASSOCIATION (2016-2020)

    AWARDED TO JOHN C. (JACK) ZINDA BY THE NATIONAL TRIAL LAWYERS ASSOCIATION (2017-2020)

    AWARDED TO JOHN C. (JACK) ZINDA (2016-2020), JOE CAPUTO (2016 – 2020) & BURGESS WILLIAMS (2016-2017) BY THE NATIONAL TRIAL LAWYERS ASSOCIATION

    AWARDED TO JOHN C. (JACK) ZINDA (2009, 2011-2012, 2014-2021), JOE CAPUTO (2019-2021), BURGESS WILLIAMS (2019-2020), NEIL SOLOMON (2020-2021), & CHRISTINA HAGEN (2021) BY SUPER LAWYERS (A THOMPSON REUTERS COMPANY)

    MEMBERS JOHN C. (JACK) ZINDA (2017-2020), JOE CAPUTO (2019-2020), BURGESS WILLIAMS (2019-2020), NEIL SOLOMON (2019-2020), COLE GUMM (2019-2020), CHRISTINA HAGEN (2020) & BRENDAN MCQUAID (2020)

    To Us, You Aren’t Just a Client, You Are a Priority

    We have over 1000 5-star Google Reviews

    I certainly received excellent service.

    The attorneys and staff are very proactive with communication, and I knew every step of the way what was happening on my case. They went above and beyond to answer my questions with satisfactory explanations.

    This is a very professional group of attorneys and support staff.

    I had an excellent experience working with the attorneys at Zinda Law Group!

    They were knowledgeable, professional, and patient. They walked me through every step of the long process of getting treatment after my car wreck and kept me updated with timeframes and next steps.

    I would absolutely recommend working with them!

    Zinda Law Group has gone above and beyond in handling my case.

    They professionally supported me through every step of the process, putting my health and life above everything else. I cannot thank them enough.

    Choose Zinda!

    Get Your Free Consultation






      El Paso West Office:

      7362 Remcon Circle
      El Paso, TX 79912

      Phone: 915-206-5820